Licences, cloud, phones and energy: automated cost checks for a 30 million group
A multi-site group with a turnover of about 30 million euro asked us to review its entire technology estate. Instead of a one-off audit we set up automated checks that read the real data: consoles, invoices, carrier portals.
The request: review everything
The group has a head office and several operating sites, a turnover of about 30 million euro and no in-house IT department. We look after its systems as its external IT lead, the role we described in Fractional IT manager.
This year management asked us to review the whole technology estate, with a clear goal: spend less without stopping the work. There were four areas to look at, and only two were really IT: licences, cloud, telecom and connectivity, energy.
An audit done once and closed in a report is out of date within months. So we chose checks that can be run again: scripts and controls that read data from the sources, meaning admin consoles, invoices and carrier portals, and produce the same list every time, up to date.
How an automated check works
- 01
Read-only access
Every check uses access that can read and not change. Logins are done by a person, ours or the client's: no tool stores or enters passwords.
- 02
Extraction
Scripts and AI tools read consoles and invoices and save the data to files: accounts and storage used, costs per service, lines and traffic.
- 03
Comparison with contracts
Each item is compared with what the company actually uses and with the contract terms: minimum durations, penalties, rented equipment.
- 04
List of actions
For each item: what can be switched off, the estimated saving, the risk and who has to decide.
- 05
Decision and repetition
Management decides, we carry it out. The same check runs again at regular intervals, so a cost that starts growing again shows up straight away.
The automated part decides nothing. It removes the data-gathering work, which is usually why these checks get postponed, and leaves the choices to people.
Microsoft 365 licences: closing without losing anything
Over the years accounts pile up: people who left the company, office mailboxes, addresses created for a project. Each with a licence paid every month.
Before closing them you need to know what they contain. We wrote a read-only script that, for each account on the list, checks how much space its OneDrive uses, how many files it holds, what is shared with others and which Teams attachments ended up in it. The result is a summary that splits the accounts into three groups: close, convert to a shared mailbox, review by hand.
Shared mailboxes are the most useful part. In Microsoft 365 they need no licence up to 50 GB, and people who need them open them from their own account (Microsoft Learn). Management, front office and department addresses stay active, the licence goes. The saving shows on the first invoice after closure.
Not everything can be cut: people who work with Word and Excel installed need a plan that includes the Office apps, so moving everyone to a cheaper licence was not an option.
AWS cloud: about a third less
The group's servers, meaning its management software and data, run on AWS, Amazon's cloud, and are paid by usage. The cost is read in Cost Explorer, the AWS tool that splits spending by service and month and forecasts the current month.
In May the bill was about 1,900 dollars a month. Since August it has been steady at around 1,300 dollars, about 30% less, and the November forecast is below 1,150. We got there by sizing servers to their real load and removing resources that were no longer needed.
There is more room, each option with its own price:
- a smaller administration server: tested on a quiet day and, if work slows down too much, rolled back in a few minutes;
- backups on cheaper storage classes: older data can move automatically to less expensive classes through lifecycle rules;
- orphaned disks and snapshots: volumes and copies left over from servers that no longer exist cost little each, but they add up;
- Savings Plans: with a one- or three-year spending commitment AWS offers discounts of up to 72% on on-demand prices (AWS). Only worth it on stable servers and with a clear horizon, because it is a commitment.
Telecom and connectivity: counting the lines
In telecom the problem is usually not the price of a line but how many there are. Backup SIMs, numbers for closed offices, spare lines activated for an emergency and never cancelled: each one costs little, and nobody counts them.
The first step is a complete list of lines, numbers and subscriptions, taken from the carrier portals. For SIMs you also need the last three months of traffic: a SIM that has sent no data in three months is a candidate for removal. Meanwhile some decisions were already clear:
- backup SIMs from a second carrier at the operating sites have been deactivated: the backup SIM included in the main contract is enough;
- before the summer the main carrier contract was reviewed with the carrier's account manager, and the effect already shows in the invoices;
- fibre finally reached one site: it costs 103 euro a month with phones included, against about 870 in an earlier offer, and allowed a satellite subscription to be switched off;
- a second satellite subscription has a one-year minimum term, the condition for not paying for the dish: we are past the halfway point, so it is better to reach the end of the term and then cancel;
- at head office the firewall and backup line can be decommissioned, and the carrier has already sent a comparison of current and future costs.
Where connectivity is essential, a backup stays. The saving comes from removing duplicates, not from leaving a site without an alternative.
Energy: the same method, on the meters
Energy is not IT and we do not manage it, but the method is the same, and it is the next step of the review.
The data is already there. The Portale Consumi run by ARERA and Acquirente Unico shows up to 36 months of consumption for each supply point, down to quarter-hour detail for electricity, with SPID login (ARERA). From there, together with the bills, you can read three things:
- baseline consumption at night and on closing days: if the sites are empty and the meter is running, something has been left on;
- contracted power compared with real peaks: power much higher than needed is paid every month in the fixed charge;
- comparison between similar sites, per opening hour or per square metre: a site that uses much more than the others deserves a closer look.
Part of the baseline is legitimate: servers, network and alarms must stay on. The point is knowing how much they weigh, and what else is there.
Where cutting is a bad idea
A cost review must also say where to spend. At the operating sites IT was already down to the minimum, and some past savings had turned into risks:
- UPS units with dead batteries: in a power dip the servers shut down abruptly, risking data loss and stopping work;
- servers close to three years old, the end of the standard warranty: a five-year life is reasonable, but from the fourth year it pays to extend the warranty, which costs far less than downtime, and to plan the replacement;
- backup NAS units with their original disks: old disks fail, and a backup on a failed disk is not a backup.
The same goes for printers: they are at the copy limit in the contract, so there is nothing to cut on the rental. If there is any margin, it lies in habits, and it has to be found together with the people who print.
The picture, item by item
| Item | What we check | Where we are |
|---|---|---|
| Microsoft 365 | Unused accounts and OneDrive contents | Closures and shared mailboxes in progress |
| AWS cloud | Costs per service, servers, backups | About -30% since May, more room to test |
| Telecom | Lines, SIMs and traffic | Duplicate backup SIMs deactivated, inventory in progress |
| Connectivity | Backup lines and satellite subscriptions | Fibre active, one satellite off, one running to term |
| Energy | Baseline, contracted power, site comparison | Next step |
| Continuity | Batteries, warranties, disks | To fund, not to cut |
So far the biggest savings have not come from haggling but from counting: what is there, what is used, what is paid for twice.
A review for your company
This work is part of the external IT lead role, but it can also be done on its own, as a first step. Write to us with how many sites you have and which cloud, telecom and licence suppliers you use: we will tell you which data we need and what we can check automatically.
How we wrote this article
At Cloudfactory we also use artificial intelligence in our editorial work: it helps us find and cross-check sources, compare data, set up the structure and polish the language. The system we use is configured by us, with instructions, examples and procedures built around the way we write. Our team checked every source, edited the text and approved the published version. The assessments and choices are Cloudfactory's, and we answer for them.
Frequently asked questions
What is an automated IT cost check?
A set of controls that read data from the sources, such as admin consoles, invoices and carrier portals, and produce a list of items to switch off or renegotiate. It can be repeated at regular intervals.
Do Microsoft 365 shared mailboxes need a licence?
No, up to 50 GB. People who use them open them from their own licensed account. Extra licences are needed only beyond 50 GB, for an expanded archive or for litigation hold.
How much can you save on AWS?
It depends on how it is set up. In the case described the cost fell by about 30% by sizing servers to real load and removing unused resources. One- or three-year spending commitments give bigger discounts, but need careful thought.
Can automated checks change the systems?
No. They use read-only access and do not enter passwords. Changes are made afterwards, once management has decided.
Where can I find the electricity consumption of each site?
In Italy, on the Portale Consumi run by ARERA and Acquirente Unico, with SPID: up to 36 months of history per supply point and, for electricity, quarter-hour detail.